nyasekai

Graveyard / Positioning

COT positioning on currencies and commodities

Do extreme futures positions in FX and commodities predict reversals?

Family
Positioning
Verdict
Dead
Cause
No edge
Buried
22 November 2026

The idea

When leveraged funds or managed money are unusually long or short a currency or commodity, the crowd is stretched. Trade against it (contrarian) or with it (follow).

How we tested it

DataSeven USD currency pairs with leveraged-fund positions, and five commodity ETFs (GLD, SLV, CPER, USO, UNG) with managed-money positions. Currency entries at a z-score of 1.5 and beyond (the commodity threshold is not stated in the note). Both directions were specified before the run. 104 weeks are needed for the z-score, so the development window is effectively 2012-2018.
PeriodCFTC data from 2010. Holdout January 2019 to November 2026.
CostsCosts and financing or borrow charged, plus a 1.5 times stress case. Currency financing used a 3-month rate differential plus 50 bp a year.
HoldoutJanuary 2019 onward, untouched until the single run.
ControlRandom twins: the signal series shifted circularly by 1 to 8 years, 300 times. Bonferroni alpha 0.025 for two variants.

Result

Currencies, holdout Sharpe contrarian / follow0.04 / −0.23
Currencies, annual net+0.07% / −0.43%
Currencies, twin p0.42 / 0.57
Currencies, holdout entries63
Commodities, holdout Sharpe contrarian / follow0.06 / −0.13
Commodities, annual net+0.46% / −1.1%
Commodities, twin p0.63 / 0.48
Commodities, holdout entries / max drawdown37 / −21%

Why it failed

Neither direction beats the random twins. Currency positioning gave nothing before or after 2019 (development Sharpe −0.06 and −0.07). The commodity ETFs carry their roll cost inside the price, so positioning cannot be separated from roll yield with free data.

What would make it worth retesting

Futures-level data with the term structure, so roll yield can be separated from positioning. For currencies, a second positioning source, or a signal built on changes rather than levels.

Test id: fxcot-fx7-event-v1, mmcot-cmdty5-event-v1. Past results of a backtest say nothing certain about the future.