Graveyard / Order flow / Binance perps
Crypto market making for a small account
Can a small trader earn the bid-ask spread by quoting both sides on a perpetual exchange?
The idea
Post a buy and a sell order around the price and earn the spread every time both fill. It is how professional market makers earn their living.
How we tested it
| Data | Test 1: current bid and ask spreads and fees for BTCUSDT, XRPUSDT, BNBUSDT and DOGEUSDT perpetuals; no backtest was built. Test 2: post-only quotes at the touch every 10 seconds with a 10-second order lifetime, on six coins, using order book data and trades with a back-of-queue fill simulation (250 ms). Test 3: a literature check of naive symmetric market making on BTC, ETH and SOL. |
|---|---|
| Period | Test 2: July to December 2023. Others not stated. |
| Costs | Maker fee at the base tier: 2 bp per side (0.02% x 2 round trip). |
| Holdout | None. |
| Control | None. |
Result
| Spread versus round-trip maker fee | the spread is smaller on every pair checked |
|---|---|
| Net per fill after a 2 bp fee, every coin and rule | −3.2 to −4.8 bp |
| Best case (front of the queue, one coin) | +1.2 bp / 0.0 bp |
| Published naive market making result | lost about 60% in 3 days, even with a rebate |
Why it failed
The entire quoted spread is smaller than the fee, so quoting at the best bid and ask cannot cover a round trip. Professional firms compete down to the minimum tick, at fee tiers with rebates that a small account cannot get. The queue simulation, assuming a place at the back of the queue, loses on every coin and every rule.
What would make it worth retesting
A maker fee at or below zero (a rebate tier), or a coin with a large tick and a measured position in its own queue from a real post-only order test.
Past results of a backtest say nothing certain about the future.