nyasekai

Graveyard / Options and volatility / US stocks

Variance risk premium timing

Does a high gap between implied and realised volatility predict strong stock returns?

Family
Options and volatility
Verdict
Dead
Cause
No edge
Buried
9 October 2026

The idea

Implied volatility usually exceeds the volatility that follows. Academic work (2009) found that when this gap is wide, the S&P 500 tends to earn high returns over the next one to four months. Hold SPY when the gap is high, stay out otherwise.

How we tested it

DataCboe VIX history and SPY. The gap is VIX squared over 12, minus the sum of squared SPY daily log returns over 21 sessions. Long SPY while the gap is at or above its trailing 252-session median, traded at the next closing auction. A second test did the same per asset over 11 ETF and volatility-index pairs.
PeriodFebruary 1994 to October 2026, split at 27 March 2020.
Costs1 bp per side; stress case 6.5 bp.
HoldoutIn-sample and out-of-sample Sharpe, plus a filter test.
ControlSPY buy and hold over the same window (Sharpe 0.65).

Result

Trades (primary)556
Sharpe full / in-sample / out-of-sample0.52 / 0.37 / 1.18
Buy-and-hold SPY Sharpe0.65
Max drawdown / profit factor−43.6% / 1.62
Sharpe at stress cost0.38
Sharpe in bear / bull / chop markets−0.78 / 2.29 / 0.01
11-pair version, Sharpe full / in / out0.59 / 0.46 / 1.15
11-pair version, legs worse than buy and hold10 of 11

Why it failed

In this daily-data form the signal adds nothing over buying and holding: the full-period Sharpe of 0.52 is below the 0.65 of simply holding SPY, and the drawdown is still −44%. An extra volatility filter lowered the out-of-sample Sharpe (0.99 against 1.18) instead of raising it, which breaks the rule that a filter must help.

What would make it worth retesting

No reopen condition is stated.

Past results of a backtest say nothing certain about the future.