Graveyard / Funds and structure
Closed-end fund tender offers
Do closed-end fund shares rise when the fund tenders for its own shares?
The idea
A closed-end fund can offer to buy back 5% to 25% of its shares near net asset value. That puts a floor under the price, and the discount should narrow. Buy when the offer is filed and hold for 20 sessions.
How we tested it
| Data | 411 closed-end funds, 214 tender-offer filings from 123 funds (SC TO-I). Event: the first filing per fund in 120 days. Long at the next open, exit at the close 20 sessions later, adjusted prices. |
|---|---|
| Period | Development 2012 to 2019, holdout from January 2020. Nothing was tuned. |
| Costs | 50 bp round trip; stress case 100 bp. |
| Holdout | Pass bar fixed in advance: holdout mean excess of at least +1.0%, t of at least 2.4, at least 30 events and a twin percentile of at least 98. |
| Control | A random-twin fund over the same dates (200 draws) and a SPY beta-adjusted benchmark. |
Result
| Holdout events | 114 |
|---|---|
| Mean net vs random-twin fund | −0.36% (t −0.42) |
| Twin percentile | 66 |
| Versus SPY | −2.0% |
Why it failed
No edge. The twin comparison removes the general drift of closed-end funds, and what remains is slightly negative. The universe contains only funds alive today, which probably flatters the long side, and the filing does not give tender size or the price-to-NAV gap at the time.
What would make it worth retesting
Only with funds that were liquidated or merged added back, and with the tender size and the discount at filing parsed and used as filters (large near-NAV tenders only).
Past results of a backtest say nothing certain about the future.