Graveyard / Funds and structure
Following activists in closed-end funds
Do closed-end funds rise after an activist files a Schedule 13D?
The idea
Activist investors sometimes build stakes of 5% or more in discounted closed-end funds and push for tenders, liquidations or open-ending. That usually narrows the discount. Buy the fund when the stake is disclosed.
How we tested it
| Data | The same closed-end fund universe as the tender test, with 2,233 Schedule 13D rows covering 218 funds. Event: the first original 13D for a fund with none in the prior 365 days. Long at the next open, exit at the close 60 sessions later. |
|---|---|
| Period | Development 2012 to 2019, holdout from January 2020. A single configuration, nothing tuned. |
| Costs | 60 bp round trip; stress case 120 bp. |
| Holdout | Pass bar fixed in advance: holdout mean excess of at least +2.0% over 60 sessions versus a random twin, t of at least 2.4, at least 30 events, twin percentile of at least 98. |
| Control | A random-twin fund over the same dates. |
Result
| Holdout events | 129 |
|---|---|
| Net excess vs random twin | +1.06% (t 0.78) |
| Pass bar | +2.0%, t 2.4 |
| Raw return | +3.2%, mostly market and fund drift |
Why it failed
A weak positive effect that is below the bar. Most of the raw +3.2% is the market and closed-end funds in general. The filing also lags the stake building by up to 10 days before 2024, so part of the move is already in the price.
What would make it worth retesting
Survivorship-free prices that include liquidated funds, or at least 250 events. The notes also name an activist-identity filter and intraday filing time, with at least 40 events.
Past results of a backtest say nothing certain about the future.