Graveyard / Funds and structure
Odd-lot tender offer strategy
Can a small holder profit from company tender offers that favour odd-lot holders?
The idea
Some company tender offers give priority to holders of fewer than 100 shares, so they are fully filled. Buy 99 shares when the offer is filed and tender them at the offer price.
How we tested it
| Data | Company tender filings (SC TO-I) from the SEC. 294 filings carried odd-lot priority wording; 108 events had usable prices. Buy 99 shares at the close of the filing date, tender at the final price at expiry. |
|---|---|
| Period | 2016 to 2026. Development 2016-2021, holdout 2022-2026. |
| Costs | 20 bp plus USD 2 per trade. |
| Holdout | Kill rule fixed in advance: fewer than 10 events a year fails. |
| Control | The same issuer on random dates, 5 draws per event. |
Result
| Holdout events | 39 (7.8 a year) |
|---|---|
| Mean net per event | +3.03% (median +3.49%) |
| Mean per event in dollars | USD 40.1 (median 30) |
| Excess over same-issuer control | −0.28% |
| Same-issuer control | +3.31% |
| Dollar result per year, one account | about USD 310 |
| Events lost to missing prices | 129 of 294 (44%) |
Why it failed
Events are rare, the dollar amount is capped by the 99-share rule, and the premium is the issuer's ordinary drift over the same window, not the odd-lot priority. A withdrawn offer in the 2020 crash lost 68%. The 44% of events lost to missing prices were mostly delisted or acquired issuers, so the real count is uncertain.
What would make it worth retesting
Prices for delisted issuers added, and at least 10 events a year with a positive excess over the control.
Past results of a backtest say nothing certain about the future.